Some comment improvements, and portaudio API improvements. Also, disabled PortAudio PulseAudio backend as it is not working properly.
All checks were successful
Building, testing and releasing LASP if it has a tag / Build-Test-Ubuntu (push) Successful in 2m35s
Building, testing and releasing LASP if it has a tag / Release-Ubuntu (push) Successful in -31s

This commit is contained in:
Anne de Jong 2024-02-06 14:59:51 +01:00
parent 7c8e6368ba
commit 7ce45e9c82
4 changed files with 302 additions and 304 deletions

View File

@ -4,7 +4,8 @@ if(LASP_HAS_PORTAUDIO)
if(WIN32)
else()
set(PA_USE_ALSA TRUE CACHE BOOL "Build PortAudio with ALSA backend")
set(PA_USE_JACK TRUE CACHE BOOL "Build PortAudio with Jack backend")
set(PA_USE_JACK FALSE CACHE BOOL "Build PortAudio with Jack backend")
set(PA_USE_PULSEAUDIO FALSE CACHE BOOL "Build PortAudio with PulseAudio backend")
# set(PA_ALSA_DYNAMIC FALSE CACHE BOOL "Build static library of ALSA")
set(PA_BUILD_SHARED_LIBS FALSE CACHE BOOL "Build static library")
endif()

View File

@ -48,6 +48,10 @@ public:
logicError,
};
// Below the only members of this class, which are public.
bool isRunning = false;
StreamError errorType{StreamError::noError};
/**
* @brief Map between error types and messages
*/
@ -61,7 +65,7 @@ public:
{StreamError::logicError, "Logic error (probably a bug)"},
};
bool isRunning = false;
/**
* @brief Check if stream has error
*
@ -69,8 +73,6 @@ public:
*/
bool error() const { return errorType != StreamError::noError; };
StreamError errorType{StreamError::noError};
std::string errorMsg() const { return errorMessages.at(errorType); }
/**

View File

@ -1,16 +1,19 @@
/* #define DEBUGTRACE_ENABLED */
#include "lasp_streammgr.h"
#include "debugtrace.hpp"
#include "lasp_biquadbank.h"
#include "lasp_indatahandler.h"
#include "lasp_thread.h"
#include <algorithm>
#include <assert.h>
#include <algorithm>
#include <functional>
#include <iostream>
#include <memory>
#include <mutex>
#include "debugtrace.hpp"
#include "lasp_biquadbank.h"
#include "lasp_indatahandler.h"
#include "lasp_thread.h"
using std::cerr;
using std::endl;
using rte = std::runtime_error;
@ -109,7 +112,6 @@ void StreamMgr::rescanDAQDevices_impl(std::function<void()> callback) {
}
}
void StreamMgr::inCallback(const DaqData &data) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
std::scoped_lock<std::mutex> lck(_inDataHandler_mtx);
@ -118,7 +120,6 @@ void StreamMgr::inCallback(const DaqData &data) {
if (std::count_if(_inputFilters.cbegin(), _inputFilters.cend(),
[](const auto &a) { return bool(a); }) > 0) {
/// Found a filter in vector of input filters. So we have to apply the
/// filters to each channel.
@ -151,7 +152,6 @@ void StreamMgr::inCallback(const DaqData &data) {
}
void StreamMgr::setSiggen(std::shared_ptr<Siggen> siggen) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
checkRightThread();
@ -179,7 +179,8 @@ void StreamMgr::setSiggen(std::shared_ptr<Siggen> siggen) {
*
* @return
*/
template <typename T> bool fillData(DaqData &data, const vd &signal) {
template <typename T>
bool fillData(DaqData &data, const vd &signal) {
/* DEBUGTRACE_ENTER; */
assert(data.nframes == signal.size());
@ -212,7 +213,6 @@ template <typename T> bool fillData(DaqData &data, const vd &signal) {
return true;
}
void StreamMgr::outCallback(DaqData &data) {
/* DEBUGTRACE_ENTER; */
std::scoped_lock<std::mutex> lck(_siggen_mtx);
@ -257,8 +257,6 @@ StreamMgr::~StreamMgr() {
// virtual methods. This was really a bug.
_inputStream.reset();
_outputStream.reset();
}
void StreamMgr::stopAllStreams() {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
@ -273,11 +271,11 @@ void StreamMgr::startStream(const DaqConfiguration &config) {
bool isInput = std::count_if(config.inchannel_config.cbegin(),
config.inchannel_config.cend(),
[](auto &i) { return i.enabled; });
[](auto &i) { return i.enabled; }) > 0;
bool isOutput = std::count_if(config.outchannel_config.cbegin(),
config.outchannel_config.cend(),
[](auto &i) { return i.enabled; });
[](auto &i) { return i.enabled; }) > 0;
// Find the first device that matches with the configuration
std::scoped_lock lck(_devices_mtx);
@ -302,19 +300,23 @@ void StreamMgr::startStream(const DaqConfiguration &config) {
bool isDuplex = isInput && isOutput;
if (!isInput && !isOutput) {
throw rte("Neither input, nor output channels enabled for "
"stream. Cannot start.");
throw rte(
"Attempted stream start failed, stream does not have any enabled "
"channels. Please first enable channels in the channel configuration.");
}
if (isInput && _inputStream) {
throw rte("Error: an input stream is already running. Please "
throw rte(
"Error: an input stream is already running. Please "
"first stop existing stream");
} else if (isOutput && _outputStream) {
throw rte("Error: output stream is already running. Please "
throw rte(
"Error: output stream is already running. Please "
"first stop existing stream");
} else if (_inputStream) {
if (_inputStream->duplexMode() && isOutput) {
throw rte("Error: output stream is already running (in duplex mode). "
throw rte(
"Error: output stream is already running (in duplex mode). "
"Please "
"first stop existing stream");
}
@ -322,13 +324,15 @@ void StreamMgr::startStream(const DaqConfiguration &config) {
if (_outputStream && isInput && _outputStream->duplexModeForced &&
config.match(*_outputStream)) {
throw rte("This device is already opened for output. If input is also "
throw rte(
"This device is already opened for output. If input is also "
"required, please enable duplex mode for this device");
}
if (_inputStream && isOutput && _inputStream->duplexModeForced &&
config.match(*_inputStream)) {
throw rte("This device is already opened for input. If output is also "
throw rte(
"This device is already opened for input. If output is also "
"required, please enable duplex mode for this device");
}
@ -353,8 +357,8 @@ void StreamMgr::startStream(const DaqConfiguration &config) {
/// Create input filters
_inputFilters.clear();
/// No input filter for monitor channel, which comes as the first input channel
/// In the list
/// No input filter for monitor channel, which comes as the first input
/// channel In the list
if (config.monitorOutput && devinfo->hasInternalOutputMonitor) {
_inputFilters.push_back(nullptr);
}
@ -398,7 +402,6 @@ void StreamMgr::startStream(const DaqConfiguration &config) {
}
}
void StreamMgr::stopStream(const StreamType t) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
checkRightThread();
@ -436,7 +439,8 @@ void StreamMgr::addInDataHandler(InDataHandler *handler) {
if (std::find(_inDataHandlers.cbegin(), _inDataHandlers.cend(), handler) !=
_inDataHandlers.cend()) {
throw std::runtime_error("Error: handler already added. Probably start() "
throw std::runtime_error(
"Error: handler already added. Probably start() "
"is called more than once on a handler object");
}
_inDataHandlers.push_back(handler);
@ -467,7 +471,6 @@ Daq::StreamStatus StreamMgr::getStreamStatus(const StreamType type) const {
}
const Daq *StreamMgr::getDaq(StreamType type) const {
checkRightThread();
if (type == StreamType::input) {

View File

@ -3,23 +3,22 @@
#include "lasp_config.h"
#if LASP_HAS_PORTAUDIO == 1
#include "lasp_portaudiodaq.h"
#include "portaudio.h"
#include <gsl-lite/gsl-lite.hpp>
#include <mutex>
#include <string>
#include "lasp_portaudiodaq.h"
#include "portaudio.h"
using rte = std::runtime_error;
using std::cerr;
using std::endl;
using std::string;
using std::to_string;
inline void throwIfError(PaError e)
{
inline void throwIfError(PaError e) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
if (e != paNoError)
{
if (e != paNoError) {
throw rte(string("PortAudio backend error: ") + Pa_GetErrorText(e));
}
}
@ -27,16 +26,14 @@ inline void throwIfError(PaError e)
/**
* @brief Device info, plus PortAudio stuff
*/
class OurPaDeviceInfo : public DeviceInfo
{
public:
class OurPaDeviceInfo : public DeviceInfo {
public:
/**
* @brief Store instance to PaDeviceInfo.
*/
PaDeviceInfo _paDevInfo;
virtual std::unique_ptr<DeviceInfo> clone() const override final
{
virtual std::unique_ptr<DeviceInfo> clone() const override final {
return std::make_unique<OurPaDeviceInfo>(*this);
}
OurPaDeviceInfo &operator=(const OurPaDeviceInfo &) = delete;
@ -44,44 +41,40 @@ public:
OurPaDeviceInfo(const PaDeviceInfo &o) : DeviceInfo(), _paDevInfo(o) {}
};
void fillPortAudioDeviceInfo(DeviceInfoList &devinfolist)
{
void fillPortAudioDeviceInfo(DeviceInfoList &devinfolist) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
try
{
bool shouldPaTerminate = false;
try {
PaError err = Pa_Initialize();
/// PortAudio says that Pa_Terminate() should not be called whenever there
/// is an error in Pa_Initialize(). This is opposite to what most examples
/// of PortAudio show.
throwIfError(err);
shouldPaTerminate = true;
auto fin = gsl::finally([&err]
{
auto fin = gsl::finally([&err] {
DEBUGTRACE_PRINT("Terminating PortAudio instance");
err = Pa_Terminate();
if (err != paNoError) {
cerr << "Error terminating PortAudio. Do not know what to do." << endl;
} });
}
});
const PaHostApiIndex apicount = Pa_GetHostApiCount();
if (apicount < 0)
{
if (apicount < 0) {
return;
}
/* const PaDeviceInfo *deviceInfo; */
const int numDevices = Pa_GetDeviceCount();
if (numDevices < 0)
{
if (numDevices < 0) {
throw rte("PortAudio could not find any devices");
}
for (us i = 0; i < (us)numDevices; i++)
{
for (us i = 0; i < (us)numDevices; i++) {
/* DEBUGTRACE_PRINT(i); */
bool hasDuplexMode = false;
const PaDeviceInfo *deviceInfo = Pa_GetDeviceInfo(i);
if (!deviceInfo)
{
if (!deviceInfo) {
throw rte("No device info struct returned");
}
OurPaDeviceInfo d(*deviceInfo);
@ -90,13 +83,13 @@ void fillPortAudioDeviceInfo(DeviceInfoList &devinfolist)
d.device_name = deviceInfo->name;
const PaHostApiInfo *hostapiinfo = Pa_GetHostApiInfo(deviceInfo->hostApi);
if (hostapiinfo == nullptr)
{
if (hostapiinfo == nullptr) {
throw std::runtime_error("Hostapi nullptr!");
}
switch (hostapiinfo->type)
{
switch (hostapiinfo->type) {
case paALSA:
// Duplex mode for alsa
hasDuplexMode = true;
d.api = portaudioALSAApi;
break;
case paASIO:
@ -148,8 +141,13 @@ void fillPortAudioDeviceInfo(DeviceInfoList &devinfolist)
}
}
catch (rte &e)
{
catch (rte &e) {
if (shouldPaTerminate) {
PaError err = Pa_Terminate();
if (err != paNoError) {
cerr << "Error terminating PortAudio. Do not know what to do." << endl;
}
}
cerr << "PortAudio backend error: " << e.what() << std::endl;
return;
}
@ -174,16 +172,14 @@ static int rawPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
const PaStreamCallbackTimeInfo *timeInfo,
PaStreamCallbackFlags statusFlags, void *userData);
class PortAudioDaq : public Daq
{
bool _shouldPaTerminate = false;
class PortAudioDaq : public Daq {
PaStream *_stream = nullptr;
std::atomic<StreamStatus::StreamError> _streamError =
StreamStatus::StreamError::noError;
InDaqCallback _incallback;
OutDaqCallback _outcallback;
public:
public:
PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
const DaqConfiguration &config);
@ -212,13 +208,11 @@ public:
};
std::unique_ptr<Daq> createPortAudioDevice(const DeviceInfo &devinfo,
const DaqConfiguration &config)
{
const DaqConfiguration &config) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
const OurPaDeviceInfo *_info =
dynamic_cast<const OurPaDeviceInfo *>(&devinfo);
if (_info == nullptr)
{
if (_info == nullptr) {
throw rte("BUG: Could not cast DeviceInfo to OurPaDeviceInfo");
}
return std::make_unique<PortAudioDaq>(*_info, config);
@ -227,38 +221,35 @@ std::unique_ptr<Daq> createPortAudioDevice(const DeviceInfo &devinfo,
static int rawPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
unsigned long framesPerBuffer,
const PaStreamCallbackTimeInfo *timeInfo,
PaStreamCallbackFlags statusFlags, void *userData)
{
PaStreamCallbackFlags statusFlags, void *userData) {
return static_cast<PortAudioDaq *>(userData)->memberPaCallback(
inputBuffer, outputBuffer, framesPerBuffer, timeInfo, statusFlags);
}
PortAudioDaq::PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
const DaqConfiguration &config)
: Daq(devinfo_gen, config)
{
: Daq(devinfo_gen, config) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
bool shouldPaTerminate = false;
try {
PaError err = Pa_Initialize();
/// PortAudio says that Pa_Terminate() should not be called whenever there
/// is an error in Pa_Initialize(). This is opposite to what most examples
/// of PortAudio show.
throwIfError(err);
// OK, Pa_Initialize successfully finished, it means we have to clean up with
// Pa_Terminate in the destructor.
_shouldPaTerminate = true;
// OK, Pa_Initialize successfully finished, it means we have to clean up
// with Pa_Terminate in the destructor.
shouldPaTerminate = true;
// Going to find the device in the list. If its there, we have to retrieve
// the index, as this is required in the PaStreamParameters struct
int devindex = -1;
for (int i = 0; i < Pa_GetDeviceCount(); i++)
{
for (int i = 0; i < Pa_GetDeviceCount(); i++) {
// DEBUGTRACE_PRINT(i);
bool ok = true;
const PaDeviceInfo *info = Pa_GetDeviceInfo(i);
if (!info)
{
if (!info) {
throw rte("No device structure returned from PortAudio");
}
ok &= string(info->name) == devinfo_gen.device_name;
@ -267,13 +258,11 @@ PortAudioDaq::PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
ok &= info->maxOutputChannels == devinfo_gen._paDevInfo.maxOutputChannels;
ok &= info->defaultSampleRate == devinfo_gen._paDevInfo.defaultSampleRate;
if (ok)
{
if (ok) {
devindex = i;
}
}
if (devindex < 0)
{
if (devindex < 0) {
throw rte(string("Device not found: ") + string(devinfo_gen.device_name));
}
@ -281,8 +270,7 @@ PortAudioDaq::PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
const Dtype dtype = dataType();
// Sample format is bit flag
PaSampleFormat format = paNonInterleaved;
switch (dtype)
{
switch (dtype) {
case Dtype::dtype_fl32:
DEBUGTRACE_PRINT("Datatype float32");
format |= paFloat32;
@ -311,19 +299,17 @@ PortAudioDaq::PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
std::unique_ptr<PaStreamParameters> instreamParams;
std::unique_ptr<PaStreamParameters> outstreamParams;
if (neninchannels() > 0)
{
instreamParams = std::make_unique<PaStreamParameters>(
PaStreamParameters({.device = devindex,
if (neninchannels() > 0) {
instreamParams = std::make_unique<PaStreamParameters>(PaStreamParameters(
{.device = devindex,
.channelCount = (int)getHighestEnabledInChannel() + 1,
.sampleFormat = format,
.suggestedLatency = framesPerBlock() / samplerate(),
.hostApiSpecificStreamInfo = nullptr}));
}
if (nenoutchannels() > 0)
{
outstreamParams = std::make_unique<PaStreamParameters>(
PaStreamParameters({.device = devindex,
if (nenoutchannels() > 0) {
outstreamParams = std::make_unique<PaStreamParameters>(PaStreamParameters(
{.device = devindex,
.channelCount = (int)getHighestEnabledOutChannel() + 1,
.sampleFormat = format,
.suggestedLatency = framesPerBlock() / samplerate(),
@ -343,28 +329,35 @@ PortAudioDaq::PortAudioDaq(const OurPaDeviceInfo &devinfo_gen,
paNoFlag, // streamFlags
rawPaCallback, this);
throwIfError(err);
assert(_stream);
} catch (rte &e) {
if (shouldPaTerminate) {
PaError err = Pa_Terminate();
if (err != paNoError) {
cerr << "Error terminating PortAudio. Do not know what to do." << endl;
}
}
throw;
}
}
void PortAudioDaq::start(InDaqCallback inCallback, OutDaqCallback outCallback)
{
void PortAudioDaq::start(InDaqCallback inCallback, OutDaqCallback outCallback) {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
assert(_stream);
if (Pa_IsStreamActive(_stream))
{
if (Pa_IsStreamActive(_stream)) {
throw rte("Stream is already running");
}
// Logical XOR
if (inCallback && outCallback)
{
throw rte("Either input or output stream possible for RtAudio. "
if (inCallback && outCallback) {
throw rte(
"Either input or output stream possible for PortAudio. "
"Stream duplex mode not provided.");
}
if (neninchannels() > 0)
{
if (!inCallback)
{
if (neninchannels() > 0) {
if (!inCallback) {
throw rte(
"Input callback given, but stream does not provide input data");
@ -372,10 +365,8 @@ void PortAudioDaq::start(InDaqCallback inCallback, OutDaqCallback outCallback)
_incallback = inCallback;
}
if (nenoutchannels() > 0)
{
if (!outCallback)
{
if (nenoutchannels() > 0) {
if (!outCallback) {
throw rte(
"Output callback given, but stream does not provide output data");
}
@ -385,86 +376,94 @@ void PortAudioDaq::start(InDaqCallback inCallback, OutDaqCallback outCallback)
PaError err = Pa_StartStream(_stream);
throwIfError(err);
}
void PortAudioDaq::stop()
{
void PortAudioDaq::stop() {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
assert(_stream);
if (Pa_IsStreamStopped(_stream))
{
if (Pa_IsStreamStopped(_stream) > 1) {
throw rte("Stream is already stopped");
}
PaError err = Pa_StopStream(_stream);
throwIfError(err);
}
Daq::StreamStatus PortAudioDaq::getStreamStatus() const
{
Daq::StreamStatus PortAudioDaq::getStreamStatus() const {
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
// Stores an error type and whether the
Daq::StreamStatus status;
// Copy over atomic flag.
status.errorType = _streamError;
// Check if stream is still running.
if (_stream)
{
if (Pa_IsStreamActive(_stream))
{
using StreamError = Daq::StreamStatus::StreamError;
Daq::StreamStatus::StreamError errortype = _streamError.load();
PaError err = Pa_IsStreamStopped(_stream);
if (err > 1) {
// Stream is stopped due to an error in the callback. The exact error type
// is filled in in the if-statement above
return status;
} else if (err == 0) {
// Still running
status.isRunning = true;
} else if (err < 0) {
// Stream encountered an error.
switch (err) {
case paInternalError:
errortype = StreamError::driverError;
break;
case paDeviceUnavailable:
errortype = StreamError::driverError;
break;
case paInputOverflowed:
errortype = StreamError::inputXRun;
break;
case paOutputUnderflowed:
errortype = StreamError::outputXRun;
break;
default:
errortype = StreamError::driverError;
cerr << "Portaudio backend error:" << Pa_GetErrorText(err) << endl;
break;
}
}
status.errorType = errortype;
return status;
}
PortAudioDaq::~PortAudioDaq()
{
PortAudioDaq::~PortAudioDaq() {
PaError err;
if (_stream)
{
if (Pa_IsStreamActive(_stream))
{
assert(_stream);
if (Pa_IsStreamActive(_stream)) {
// Stop the stream first
stop();
}
err = Pa_CloseStream(_stream);
_stream = nullptr;
if (err != paNoError)
{
if (err != paNoError) {
cerr << "Error closing PortAudio stream. Do not know what to do." << endl;
}
assert(_shouldPaTerminate);
}
if (_shouldPaTerminate)
{
err = Pa_Terminate();
if (err != paNoError)
{
if (err != paNoError) {
cerr << "Error terminating PortAudio. Do not know what to do." << endl;
}
}
}
int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
unsigned long framesPerBuffer,
const PaStreamCallbackTimeInfo *timeInfo,
PaStreamCallbackFlags statusFlags)
{
DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
PaStreamCallbackFlags statusFlags) {
// DEBUGTRACE_ENTER;
typedef Daq::StreamStatus::StreamError se;
if (statusFlags & paPrimingOutput)
{
if (statusFlags & paPrimingOutput) {
// Initial output buffers generated. So nothing with input yet
return paContinue;
}
if ((statusFlags & paInputUnderflow) || (statusFlags & paInputOverflow))
{
if ((statusFlags & paInputUnderflow) || (statusFlags & paInputOverflow)) {
_streamError = se::inputXRun;
return paAbort;
}
if ((statusFlags & paOutputUnderflow) || (statusFlags & paOutputOverflow))
{
if ((statusFlags & paOutputUnderflow) || (statusFlags & paOutputOverflow)) {
_streamError = se::outputXRun;
return paAbort;
}
if (framesPerBuffer != framesPerBlock())
{
if (framesPerBuffer != framesPerBlock()) {
cerr << "Logic error: expected a block size of: " << framesPerBlock()
<< endl;
_streamError = se::logicError;
@ -476,8 +475,7 @@ int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
const auto &dtype_descr = dtypeDescr();
const auto dtype = dataType();
const us sw = dtype_descr.sw;
if (inputBuffer)
{
if (inputBuffer) {
assert(_incallback);
std::vector<byte_t *> ptrs;
ptrs.reserve(neninchannels);
@ -489,10 +487,8 @@ int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
/// Only pass on the pointers of the channels we want. inputBuffer is
/// noninterleaved, as specified in PortAudioDaq constructor.
for (us ch = ch_min; ch <= ch_max; ch++)
{
if (inchannel_config.at(ch).enabled)
{
for (us ch = ch_min; ch <= ch_max; ch++) {
if (inchannel_config.at(ch).enabled) {
byte_t *ch_ptr =
reinterpret_cast<byte_t **>(const_cast<void *>(inputBuffer))[ch];
ptrs.push_back(ch_ptr);
@ -504,8 +500,7 @@ int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
_incallback(d);
}
if (outputBuffer)
{
if (outputBuffer) {
assert(_outcallback);
std::vector<byte_t *> ptrs;
ptrs.reserve(nenoutchannels);
@ -517,10 +512,8 @@ int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
assert(ch_min < noutchannels);
assert(ch_max < noutchannels);
/// Only pass on the pointers of the channels we want
for (us ch = ch_min; ch <= ch_max; ch++)
{
if (outchannel_config.at(ch).enabled)
{
for (us ch = ch_min; ch <= ch_max; ch++) {
if (outchannel_config.at(ch).enabled) {
byte_t *ch_ptr = reinterpret_cast<byte_t **>(outputBuffer)[ch];
ptrs.push_back(ch_ptr);
}
@ -530,8 +523,7 @@ int PortAudioDaq::memberPaCallback(const void *inputBuffer, void *outputBuffer,
_outcallback(d);
// Copy over the buffer
us j = 0;
for (auto ptr : ptrs)
{
for (auto ptr : ptrs) {
d.copyToRaw(j, ptr);
j++;
}